I don't think I can recall what started as a pistol with a sub par finish becoming the darling of beginning Model 1911 pistol collectors. In an effort to speed up WWI production of the Model of 1911 pistol, Colt skipped the final polish operation. This resulted in a rough dark finish that was not durable, and tended to flake off in patches with only slight handling. Also, almost half of Model 1911 pistol production falls into this "Black Army" category.
Excited collectors will ask if their newly found nickel plated Model 1911 that falls into mid to late 1918 production is one of the elusive "Black Army" models. With the nickel plating it now falls more into the "Old Silver" category.
Charles Clawson described the WWI produced 1911 pistol as having a "black finish", and from this the "Black Army" was elevated to mysterious and elusive proportions.
On this late production Model 1911 the Eagle/S12 and serial number were stamped after the pistol was finished. This caused the bluing to flake off around the markings in a halo effect.
https://www.milsurps.com/images/impo.../06/33v7-1.jpg
https://www.milsurps.com/images/impo.../2s7cmls-1.jpg
https://www.milsurps.com/images/impo.../20zwuh3-1.jpg