11 Attachment(s)
Further to the carbine in the pictures..............
Quote:
Originally Posted by
boltaction
I used to own that RNWMP carbine many years ago. It's a nice one, but I've advised the seller for the estate that it is likely not RNWMP. There is some variation, but for the most part, the Ross and Enfield rifles/carbines owned by the RNWMP were stamped with an oval stamp, not a crescent shape. This one has a crescent shaped mark, which is not described in Phillips' book and was as far as I recall only used on the Winchesters, which were of course NWMP. The "Royal" designation was added after their time. There is no stippling around the edges of the stamp. The carbine has had its stock lightly sanded and a coat of varnish put on, and that was another issue with the stamp. The Canadian Forces' M&D stamp and the rack number are rather faint, but the RNWMP stamp is deeper and newer. Since the stamps, if correct, would have been applied around the same time, they should all be equally faint. There is a faint other mark visible. IMO, the carbine may well have been in the Mounted Police service, based on the number stamped on the butt, but it has been massaged; I believe the RNWMP stamp is a fake. Others may disagree, but there are a lot of MP fakes out there. It is a sweet little carbine, mismatch bolt but otherwise complete and in nice shape. I have three, so didn't want it back even with a lower price, but if I didn't have one, I would buy it as a carbine, not as an RNWMP item. I believe the seller is going to lower the price.
I thought I would include a few pictures of the LEC carbine including the buttstock for interest sake, so others can see what I am referring to. That stamp also has the appearance of being doublestruck. Nice little carbine though and would probably shoot very nicely.
The last three photos are of the RNWMP stamp on the butts of my Ross carbine and my LEC carbine. You can see that the stamp on the LEC is somewhat oval, while the one applied to the Ross is circular. Both are correct, and have a fine line of stippling around the edges which has not been accurately replicated on fake stamps. The LEC's stamps are faint because it too has been varnished at some point, but it can be seen that the RNWMP and M&D stamps are equally faint. Actually, the M&D stamp is a little deeper so shows up better. Must have been given a better whack with the hammer when being applied.
Attachment 42323Attachment 42335Attachment 42334Attachment 42333Attachment 42332Attachment 42331Attachment 42327Attachment 42324Attachment 42338Attachment 42336Attachment 42337