what's the big deal with the bavarian carbines at cmp?

[goo]

just collector value?

Information

Warning: This is a relatively older thread This discussion is older than 360 days. Some information contained in it may no longer be current.

[Bill Hollinger]

They are another variant with more and a different history behind them.

[painter777]

Most say they were well taken care of.

Charlie

[GCK]

They were taking care of if you like a blue/black barrel with the name almost buffed off and a receiver you can barely read the maker under the blue finnish.The potbelly stock is also covered with some kind of polyurithane. The only good thing about the one I got is the type 1 band and a nice Rock-Ola front sight. There is no way of restoring it to any GI look. I will probably just give it to one of the grandkids to lug around the desert shooting.

[JimF4M1s (Deceased)]

I can see why people might want another variant, something different.

I don't like all the markings that they put on them. I know, history of the Carbine and all. It's just a variant that doesn't have much of an attraction to me. For someone else it might be all they collect.

That's the fun of the Carbine. It has something for each of us.

[FTD1167]

Found a real nice one the other day at a gunshop. Priced low and had some
real early parts. Closer I looked at it, they had filed off "U.S." of "U.S. carbine"
on top.
Ruined it for for me. Handed it back right quick..

[dnikkor]

They were taking care of if you like a blue/black barrel with the name almost buffed off and a receiver you can barely read the maker under the blue finnish.The potbelly stock is also covered with some kind of polyurithane. The only good thing about the one I got is the type 1 band and a nice Rock-Ola front sight. There is no way of restoring it to any GI look. I will probably just give it to one of the grandkids to lug around the desert shooting.

Sorry you are not happy with your Austrian return. the black oxide finish is nice and even on my Rockola with the name clearly visible behind the Type 3 sight as well as on the barrel. I wasn't lucky enough to get a type 1 band, but I did get a very nice replacement Winchester non-potbellied M2 stock. The finish on the stock makes it feel like it has been lovingly "boned" and only needed an easy cleaning with Murphy's soap. The "plum" trigger housing, while a little gaudy, makes for a nice conversation piece.

Mine was last issued to an Austrian Gendarme named G. Weber. Can you name the last person who was issued any of your non-Austrian M1 carbines?

Would I have preferred a "pretty" USGI carbine as last issued to an American GI?....sure.

Am I disappointed with my Austrian Rockola?....not a bit....other than not scoring a Type 1 barrel band like you did.

Let me know if your lucky grandkid wants to have a cool looking bayonet mount instead of that skinny Plain Jane Type 1 band. I'll even throw in the bayonet.

[GCK]

I guess it was just "luck of the draw" I have a bunch of nice carbines from CMP and will order more.

[coneten]

[/IMG][/IMG]This is the link.German police M1 carbine - Military Surplus Collectors Forums.
The pics.

[coneten]

FTD1167, That carbine you saw sounds alot like the one I just posted pics of. What were the asking price wise?