Carbine Club Data Sheet Question

[painter777]

I have this thick railed, Long Tab Mag Catch.
IIRC Per Riesch it would be a Type IA.
On the CC Data Sheet.... This would be the Type II.... Correct?

I'll probably have a few more questions.
Can't help but get nervous every time I try to fill one of these out
I never tried this hard back in school.

TIA,
Charlie-painter777

Information

Warning: This is a relatively older thread This discussion is older than 360 days. Some information contained in it may no longer be current.

[tenOC]

I use a pencil.

[painter777]

Now I have to start over.
And here I thought my choice of Crayon color was perfect.......... I never could color between the lines.

Thx Guys, I'm going with a Type II per the CC Datasheet. First two are both with the serrations, this one is long tab, thick rail so it must be the CC Data's Type II.

[JimF4M1s (Deceased)]

Charlie,

In "War Baby" page 304 bottom picture shows a picture of the plain long faced mag catch.
Page 307 has drawings and calls it a "Type A variation 2"
The CC data sheet shows it as number 2.

Room for confusion?

[painter777]

Thx Jim,

After I looked closer at the CC Data Sheet I could see that :
#1 Mag catch has serrations, thick rail and long tab/face
#1A Mag catch has serrations and thick rail, but has the short tab/face
#2 No serrations , has thick rail and long tab/face
#3 Plain short tab/face and still has the thick rail
#4 The M stamped short tab/face with the thinner rail

Riesch vs CC Data Sheet
Mag Catch:
Type I= CC Type 1
Type IA = CC Type 2
Type II= CC Type 1A
Type IIA= CC Type 3
Type III= CC Type 4

Then Riesch goes on to show the M marked catch with the short face/tab and thin rail.
CC Data Sheet shows as #4 what I believe is the same per Riesch- A short faced/tab, thin railed catch.

But the CC data sheet shows a #4A catch with I think is a Serif M, and should also be short face/tab and thin rail.
CC data sheet then lists the Underlined M as #5, which has the short face/tab and the extended arm support for the 30rd mags.

That's enough for me..... I have a Type 2 catch per the data sheet and happy about moving on.

Thx,
Charlie-painter777