Advise on retro build kits

[SPAD 124]

I'm interested in starting a retro build. A few years ago I had a Century C15A1 that I liked for the history of it, but it wasn't a very good rifle, FTEs and not very accurate. I traded it off some time ago and bought a M&P Sport last year which is far and away a better rifle.

Anyway, even though I like the Sport, I still want a retro. I think I've cleaned and stripped the C15 and my M&P enough that I understand how an AR goes together and I'm ready to tackle a retro build. But I want a better functioning rifle than the C15A1 was. I've looked at some of the M16A1 kits that are out there now and the best condition kit seems to be the one from Gunthings. The metal parts still seem to have most of their park, and the stock and handguards look pretty good. Of course from pics on the internet its hard to tell internal wear. All the LPK parts have already been changed to semi auto. Plus, they'll add a new 1:9 barrel with the FS installed. All that is needed is a stripped lower, which I have.

McKay also seems to have good quality kits and they offer 1:7 barrels.

The reviews on the Gunparts and Sarco kits don't seem to stack up. Most reviewers seem to comment that the kits are pretty worn.

My other option is to get a new C7 upper (A1 with shell deflector) from RGuns, barrel it, and add A1 stock and handguards (I already have some nice handguards). If I went this route I'd probably get the Gunthings or McKay barrel anyway.

Are there any options I've overlooked?

Thanks in advance for any opinions!

Tim

Information

Warning: This is a relatively older thread This discussion is older than 360 days. Some information contained in it may no longer be current.

[Bill Hollinger]

Try Nodak Spuds for a retro lower. NoDak Spud Retro Lowers The M16A1 kits do have worn finishes however you can use John Norrell's Grayish-Black flat to take it back to a beautiful finish and it is simple. John Norrell Arms - FAQ's

Here is a picture of my Commando mock up that I did with a genuine Colt SP1. The finishes are identical.

[SPAD 124]

Thanks Bill,

Even though I have an extra lower I thought I might get a NoDak, or, a McKay. From the NoDak website it looks like they start with a McKay.

Norrell looks like a good option. Your builds came out very nice!

[imarangemaster]

You mean a retro like this? Check AR15.com Retro forum at AR-15 / M-16 Retro Forum - AR15.COM

[Vincent]

Attachment 55441

+1 for the NoDak retro lower.

I am very happy with the one I assembled.