Swiss Briquet Model 1852 Short Sword?

[Eaglelord17]

Hi all,

I just recently decided to take a plunge into buying a sword as I have never bought one and figured it would be a neat addition for my Swiss collection. I ordered this sword that was advertised as a Swiss Briquet Model 1852 Short Sword from a dealer I have purchased from before and I trust so I never asked for any photos.

Now that its in my hands I am looking at it and I am not sure it is actually a Swiss 1852 Short Sword or if it is a modern copy or someone elses variant (the sword is based off of a French XI short sword so many different countries would have variants). I am not experienced in swords at all and would like some second opinions on it. I also know swords are one of the most faked things out there and it can be very easy to get a repro instead of the real thing.

The things that are throwing red flags for me are the fact that it is slightly different in comparison to photos I have compared to online, such as different pommel portion, different scabbard mounting system, the handle appears to be a bit different in shape, some really crude filing work on part of the handguard which I don't think the Swiss would have had any part in, and there is no markings of any sort that I have been able to locate on there, and there is a glued leather portion on the handguard to prevent the sword from rubbing on the scabbard.

Any thoughts would be appreciated as I don't know if I should be asking to return it at this point.

Information

Warning: This is a relatively older thread This discussion is older than 360 days. Some information contained in it may no longer be current.

[Pierre]

Please tell me that's not from CoGun?

[Eaglelord17]

No, its from a Canadian dealer of small arms. I have dealt with him many times in the past but he specializes more in the firearms side of things

[Pierre]

It looks legit, for sure. I suppose it is all about trust. I assume there's no paperwork?
I'd love to have it myself.

P

[Patrick Chadwick]

Nothing against swords, but isn't this the wrong forum?

---------- Post added at 04:06 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:03 PM ----------

The things that are throwing red flags for me are the fact that it is slightly different in comparison to photos I have compared to online, such as different pommel portion, different scabbard mounting system, the handle appears to be a bit different in shape, some really crude filing work on part of the handguard which I don't think the Swiss would have had any part in, and there is no markings of any sort that I have been able to locate on there, and there is a glued leather portion on the handguard to prevent the sword from rubbing on the scabbard.

Any thoughts would be appreciated as I don't know if I should be asking to return it at this point.

Sub-standard workmanship plus no markings = not a Swiss weapon. Send it back.

P.S. It could be a genuine blade that has been "recycled" with a poorly finished modern casting for the handle.

[Eaglelord17]

It might possibly be the wrong forum, I just didn't want to sign up for another one. I figured there would hopefully be some Swiss collectors on here knowledgable about this.

[Aragorn243]

I'm with Patrick on this one. No markings and questionable workmanship.

[Eaglelord17]

Well I am going to try and return it for in store credit. I have never had a issue with him, so I am going to give him the benefit of the doubt (plus he has lots of things I want which I know are authentic).

[RC20]

If its related to a Swiss rifle or even arms I am fine with the posting.