Printable View
I find the S'G' carbine one of the most interesting carbine due to its history and rarity. But, watching GB and AA the S'G' appears to be one of the least popular carbines being sold. Yet it is priced at the ODCMP at the same price as the Rock-Ola and Winchester.
What's the take on the S'G' on the forum, do most of you have one in your collection?
Still looking.....Frank
Right now the internet sale sites are awash with carbines and most any kind of so called collectible. Its the economy is probably a good answer. Another reason I would guess generic rebuilt S'G' are at cmp prices on the internet is purely price of parts and scarcity of such and how much you will have in a restored IP or S'G'. I think the people restoring the IP's are keeping the parts cost high for the S'G' guns. Also with the proliferation of repro parts and the increasing good quality of such is hard to tell the difference so people may just be buying the repro parts from the Riverbanks, abcleighs, and L&S's of the world. All this creates a lot of confusion for newbies, us former newbies, the collector wannabees and finally for the pure collectors. I probably have just added to the confusion, my wife says I can't explain crap.
At least 1Quote:
Originally Posted by RangeHound
At least 1
Jim and Jim,
At least one? Your not sure???.....Frank
No, I'm positively sure I have more. :thup:
His question was just "do most of you have one in your collection"
I was just being a wise guy.:madsmile:
I know Jim, I was just being a wise guy too.....Frank
https://www.milsurps.com/images/imported/deleted.gif
I ran into a old timer selling the two worst Garands ever in a gun show parking lot headed back to his car.No sale at $750 each. I got the story about how they were his sisters late husbands and he had priced everything in a book and nothing was selling. We went to house the next day to see the other stuff and he brought out the S'G' in the picture.It was my 4th Carbine but I had no idea what I had bought. After someone explained it to me and gave me some books to read I was hooked. Now carbines will probally be the death of me.
Sir, that is the understatement of the year for most of us.... :madsmile:Quote:
Originally Posted by Curt
I don't know what I'm going to do when my favorite drug - I mean gun dealer (goes by the name Orest???) sells out of his last carbine... guess I will go broke paying the online prices.... :dunno:
My first to hold and shoot was an Inland in Viet Nam.
My first to own was a Rock-Ola. Hooked from there.
No really she is gonna kill me!!!!!!Quote:
Originally Posted by Tired Retired
Back in 2006 I saw an ad on GunsAmerica for a Saginaw S'G' for $850. Guy in the ad said he was selling it for an estate, claimed it had been in the same family since the end of WW2. I had sort of a positive hunch so I went ahead and bought it, Turned out to be an original unaltered S'G". Flip sight, Type I barrel band (real ones), S'G" parts and even an IP marked mag catch. S'G" cartouched high wood stock, felt like I'd won at bingo!. Sold it a year later on GB for twice what I'd paid for it. Wish I still had it!
Apparently they are fairly uncommon and considering their history it would have to be a special carbine. My first carbine (until last month my only carbine) was bought in the late 60s for $150. I just used it to take camping and shooting with little regard for how I handled it. I had 7 15r and 3 genuine 30s, so that was that. It was a Winchester and I stumbled upon this site and started to take a very close look at the carbine. The wonderful people here (especially BQ) led me through the process. It was remarkable how a new owner can look but not see with these carbines. I now know a lot more about these things and after buying the latest one an NPM, I can really see how this can become habit forming. Each carbine while the same as all the others is uniquely different, each has a story to tell, to a much greater extent than the Garand. They are and always will be a pure example of Industrial Art in its greatest form. We and no other country could do this; 6 million in three years. The fact that after all these years, they endure says volumes about the design and quality. I want an S'G', just as an example of how, against great resistance, success was snatched from the jaws of failure by one determined talented man, William Doerfner.
Here is my Saginaw S'G' M1 Carbine that I bought in Nov 2001 for $428:
[IMG]https://www.milsurps.com/vbpgimage.p...3&d=1262561364[/IMG]
:D RonJon
S'G' $350
Hi MJ,
Nice to see your still taking good care of that one.
I'm sure your mess kit also ;-)
Always nice seeing your pics !
Cheers,
Charlie-painter777
https://www.milsurps.com/images/imported/deleted.gif
https://www.milsurps.com/images/imported/deleted.gif
We had three large and two small shipments come through our base armory and I recall a total of just over 700carbines during my watch. That doesn't include other WW2 arms we serviced and issued to the CIDG's, ARVN's and security teams and very nasty other peoples around the central highlands in '67.
Very nice and great collection. Thanks for sharing. Was the reputation for the carbine as bad with the ARVNS, etc as it was from the vets from Korea?
Quote:
Originally Posted by MJ1
Different place on the hammer for the S'G' marking. Does anyone have a picture of another in that location?
https://www.milsurps.com/images/imported/deleted.gif
No big deal I'll stamp it some place else next time,,LOL.
Check this one out with the zoom,
M1 Carbine item, Unique "Dogleg" type S'G' (E13) - eBay (item 120513168700 end time Jan-09-10 19:29:33 PST)
Sold for $166.10
