Question on relative rarity or value of Carbine Makers.

[JimF4M1s (Deceased)]

Mike in NC is correct.

S.G. made about 6.4%
NPM made about 6.7%

But is that enough of a difference to effect price, I don't know.

As stated, condition is everything.

Some collect any good condition gun. Others try and get all the makers first, then varients. Some folks want to specialize in a single maker. There isn't any rhyme or reason to our addiction.