Smith And Weaaon Victory Model

[BuckMark22]

I have a Smith And Wesson 38 victory model (I Think Its A K frame not sure) all numbers match barrel,frame,cylender. on the top strap it has a flaming bomb the it says U.S. Property GHD stamped on the 5 inch barrel is 38spcl, WHEN I SHOT A 38SPCL OUT OF IT THE CASE CAME OUT SPLIT, I DID IT TWO MORE TIMES WITH THE SAME THING. Is this gun restamped 38spcl, and really a 38s&w. If it was restamped where can I get a 38spcl for a K frame gun. or is it not a K frame. sorry about my lack of understanding. I am still learning. Please help I want to give this gun to my son when he gets out of the police accadamy. Thanks for your Time. And thanks for letting me in your fourm. BuckMark22.

Information

Warning: This is a relatively older thread This discussion is older than 360 days. Some information contained in it may no longer be current.

[Johnny Peppers]

Your S&W is a K frame, and from your description sounds like one that was originally chambered in .38 S&W. Since the .38 S&W was not a popular caliber in the U.S. the cylinders were reamed in the forward part of the cylinder to let a .38 S&W Special chamber. Since the .38 S&W cartridge is larger in diameter than the .38 Special the cases expand, and sometimes split as in your case.

I would not feel comfortable giving the revolver to someone in light of the problem you describe.

[browningautorifle]

Johnny is bang on of course... You can still shoot 38S&W out of it though, then you won't split brass any more. But now it's marked for the new cartridge. You could also fit it with a model 10 cylinder as I've done past. Then it has no collector's value.

[A square 10]

i would be a little concerned with the special cartridge overstressing the S&W ctg cylinder , but then thats just me ,

correct me if im wrong - the actual "V"ictory models were made for US issue and designed in special cartridge , the S&W cartridge models were actually pre-victory and not designed for the newer special cartridge ?

[browningautorifle]

i would be a little concerned with the special cartridge overstressing the S&W ctg cylinder

They'll handle it fine. They aren't weaker...just a different cartridge. Remember, they made the same gun in both cartridges at the same time in the same factory...

[A square 10]

thats good to know , i don't know a lot of metallurgy or the modifications of these revolvers - ive got both a pre-victory commonwealth issue 38S&W and a "V"ictory in 38 spcl so i don't have to make any choices this way , but i appreciate the insight for future reference ,

i do know better than to shoot 45 acp in my webley 455s , that was where i was coming from ,