Unissued WWI Colt 1911 on GB

[6167]

In my opinion, something 100 years old that looks "new" and has crisp markings, coatings, no discoloration, no waves or scuffing at the sharp edges is very suspect.
Metallurgy alone tells us this is unlikely.
I have seen "brand new" in the box Inglis High Powers with their decals and even though they are "never used" , they still look like they have been stored for 70 odd years with some residual lube on them in places.
I agree with CplSteves analogy of the pics.
Examining that WW1 piece for any sign of recent draw file or higher than the original steel ratio of nickel steel showing micro welding infill should have been a high priority for anyone vetting that one.

I recently purchased a Colt 1911A1 from 1943 that is a solid 8.5/9 out of 10 and it can pick it up, proudly show it to someone, wipe it down and put it back in the safe without fear. That's my speed...really nice, well cared for.
What more should we ask for?