choosing between 1903a3s

[Rumpelhardt]

As the title says I'm looking at two 1903a3s. One is a Remington and the other is a Smith Corona. Both look to be in good condition and the prices are close. Is there anything that all things equal would recommend one manufacturer over the other or should I just go for the one that is the best deal?
Thank you in advance for any thoughts on this.

Information

Warning: This is a relatively older thread This discussion is older than 360 days. Some information contained in it may no longer be current.

[Doug Rammel]

pictures would help. If they are in the same shape ( stock , bore condition ) etc. I'd take ths SC. Better option would be get them both

[tomwatts]

All things being equal the SC is the rarer of the two.
I would choose the SC, you can always get a Remington later!
If all things are not equal, go with the one that has the most original parts and looks the best!
My .02

[Rick the Librarian]

I agree - if both were original, go with the Smith-Corona. If both are made up of mixed parts and/or have been refinished, go with the one in the best condition and with the most original parts.