How Clean Does Brass Used with Blackpowder Need to Get?

[RossMkIIEnjoyer]

Hi,
I fired my first blackpowder cartridge handloads yesterday and began cleaning immediately. I rinsed my cases, decapped them, then soaked them in hot water with some dawn dish soap. I then dried them and tumbled them. After maybe 12 hours they were shiny on the outside again but the primer pockets and the bottom of inside the cases still have black spots. I soaked them again today and they are in the tumbler again while I sleep.

Is it normal to not get every speck of blackpowder residue out? Will the life of these shells be cut short? Or am I concerned about nothing?

Information

Warning: This is a relatively older thread This discussion is older than 360 days. Some information contained in it may no longer be current.

[browningautorifle]

Pin tumbling seems to be replacing corn cob media tumbling/vibrating

That's what I use and would recommend. Three hours works and returns the brass to new look. Dump your brass into the soapy solution on the firing line as soon as possible. The firing action has already driven the powder into the brass but that will prolong it's life.

When using the stainless steel pins and lemme shine and dawn, a little is better than a lot. Literally a few drops of dawn and a teaspoon of lemme shine or your brass will tarnish again as soon as it's dry. More is not better. I also start with hot water and rinse with hot water.

[RossMkIIEnjoyer]

Thanks,
I looked at a wet tumbler with the stainless pins but didn't want to spend the money. Looks like once I can swing it, I'll have to get one. I currently have a vibratory tumbler with fresh corn cob media. I was going to put extra polishing compound in but all that I had left was a couple drops. The brass looks fairly clean now but I'll have to keep an eye on it I guess. I wouldn't be so worried if these shells weren't so expensive and didn't have such a lead time.

[browningautorifle]

I looked at a wet tumbler with the stainless pins but didn't want to spend the money.

I understand you completely and had the exact same thoughts years ago. Then I would endure hours of vibra tumbling when my media started to degrade for only mediocre results. This cleans completely and no more buying media. You'll learn the hardships though, noisy, messy, have to keep the pins policed up and how to dry your brass effectively. I had to read miles of opinions to glean what I needed. Including why my brass was turning dark again after polishing...

[ssgross]

Pin tumbling seems to be replacing corn cob media tumbling/vibrating since it gives excellent results with no dus

I pin tumble range brass. My own brass that never hits the floor gets walnut media tumbled for 2-3 reloads, then pin tumbled (no reason other than time/hassle drying...even with a dryer). I use walnut media too for tumbling to de-grease after sizing or assembling. very quick for this.

[browningautorifle]

Love pin tumbling. Did not realize how much I detested the dusty mess of corn cob/walnut media. With pins the nasty munitions residue goes down the drain and does not stay around your reloading area as lead/carbon media dust. Pins give better results and clean primer pockets in a few hours. No worries about any case lube or wet media remaining on the inside of the case.

Agreed on all this...

My own brass that never hits the floor gets walnut media tumbled for 2-3 reloads, then pin tumbled (no reason other than time/hassle drying...even with a dryer).

Yes, a hassle but the end product...

I spread my brass out on a flat area on a garbage bag and pins too to dry. Works better than the oven or the dryer. Just leave it 24 hours. Most people can't get away with this...

[old tanker]

I keep a wide mouth plastic jug with a screw top filled with soapy water in the range kit. The brass goes in it as soon as practical after firing. Riding in the back of the truck from some ranges it is pretty well tumbled by the time I hit the highway.

[CINDERS]

I use distilled water for sonic cleaning after tumbling and also rinsing the cases if you use normal tap water the minerals in it tend to discolour and streak when dried and looks bad.