Inspection Stamp Quiz

[Rick B]

Can you tell me which of these are real and which are fake. Their 1 thru 11 .

And the answers will not be reveal right away. Rick B


#1


#2


#3


#4


#5


#6


#7


#8


#9


#10


#11

Information

Warning: This is a relatively older thread This discussion is older than 360 days. Some information contained in it may no longer be current.

[gunner]

Mmhhh. 4,5,11 a fake ???

Regards

Gunner

[AKA Hugh Uno]

I'll guess and say they are either ALL FAKE or ALL OK? LOL

[Bill Hollinger]

#3, #6, and #10 real? Maybe #2???

[snapperm1c]

Good post. When you give us the answers, will you also explain the characteristics that define the fakes? What do you look for to determine the fakes?

SN1

[Rick B]

Good post. When you give us the answers, will you also explain the characteristics that define the fakes? What do you look for to determine the fakes?

SN1

Yes I will and what I look for is both stamps being different than a original. Next I look at letter placement to originals. This is to box edges and to each other. Then I attack the crossed cannons which have so many tiny details that you can pick out more there.

The forgers have gotten really good after about 10 solid years of them being made. Some are good enough that you really have to look at them up close and compare on a good computer system and monitor.

Then I look for specifics that no one know's or have discussed as of yet on the wood itself and see if it is the correct time frame. Rick B

[snapperm1c]

Thanks, I look forward to the learning experience...

I'd say 1,4,5,and 9 are fakes, but your pics are not of sufficient resolution to get into the nitty gritty of wood/stamp interface, etc.


SN1

[Rick B]

Thanks, I look forward to the learning experience...

I'd say 1,4,5,and 9 are fakes, but your pics are not of sufficient resolution to get into the nitty gritty of wood/stamp interface, etc.


SN1

hate to say it but there is more than enough resolution in these to see the fakes. I have found some people just have a hard time with details even when a difference is pointed out. It is just something that happens in life. This test is a good example of this.


I have been lucky enough to photograph thousands of real stampings and handled many more thousands of stocks. I own well over 500 at this time. I even researched the Italian ones and have many different markings on them. I like looking in detail at stocks. Rick B

[snapperm1c]

I anxiously await your detailed wxplanation regarding the fakes.

SN1

[Ramboueille]

Can you tell me which of these are real and which are fake. Their 1 thru 11 .

And the answers will not be reveal right away. Rick B

Rick,

On a second evaluation, I think they are all fake.

I'm not certain on the last two. Tough quiz!