mauser vs. lee enfield?

[enfieldman]

I need some help in making a decision..
I have an 8mm mod98 mauser, factory 42 and 1939 stamped manufacture.
Is all matching except butt plate and forward stock ring around bayonet lug area.
Has nazi markings and codes intact, 80-85% bluing, NO rust, stock in great shape - no cracks
or dings. Nice bore and shoots great. Value???
My delima - another collector wants it badly and has badgered me for some time now.
He knows i have a weakness for Lee Enfields!! So he just offer me a 1942 Long Branch
No.4Mk1* in just as good condition/or better (all matching, etc.).
Clearly on monetary value, would this be an EVEN trade????
On a mauser vs. lee enfield, would this be an EVEN trade???? Help Please..

Information

Warning: This is a relatively older thread This discussion is older than 360 days. Some information contained in it may no longer be current.

[lude92]

i dont know the value on the rifles but i keep the mauser because of the history but the enfield has history too but i keep the mauser thats just me.

[NRA]

I would think your friend would have to kick in a couple of bills to make that trade even

[lude92]

to NRA agree

[RobD]

Not having seen either rifle, but if the descriptions are correct, I would guess that the Mauser is worth about 2x the value of the No 4, but the No 4 is a much better rifle. And has a proud, as opposed to shameful, history.

[Maxwell Smart]

And has a proud, as opposed to shameful, history.

None of which is the rifle's fault.

I am no fan of the NSDAP or its actions, but consider this: which otherwise civilized country was the first to use the concentration camp against civilians in modern times - a hint, the guards would likely have had 303 ammuntion on them.

[Beerhunter]

I am no fan of the NSDAP or its actions, but consider this: which otherwise civilized country was the first to use the concentration camp against civilians in modern times - a hint, the guards would likely have had 303 ammuntion on them.

I'm assuming that you don't mean the one that having deliberately starved political inmates to death, went on to expand the system to murder millions of innocent men, woman an children.

I'm no fan of concentration camps either.

[enfieldman]

Hope this doesn`t become a political forum!
Collecting is just good sport and great fun..
Here`s something: My dad was an allied combat soldier during WWll, but for
all that he still admired his opponents` superb weaponry (K98), as do i.
I just admire Lee Enfields more!!

[Maxwell Smart]

Hope this doesn`t become a political forum!
Collecting is just good sport and great fun..

No, I wasn't looking to start a political debate.

I suppose that the point I was trying to make is that war is a dreadful business for all concerned, and we should not assume the "our" side was always good, while "theirs" was always bad.

[Beerhunter]

Hope this doesn`t become a political forum!
Collecting is just good sport and great fun..
Here`s something: My dad was an allied combat soldier during WWll, but for
all that he still admired his opponents` superb weaponry (K98), as do i.
I just admire Lee Enfields more!!

I agree with you and my post was an ill-advised reaction.

However I disagree about the Kar98k. (I own one of them, as well as my Lee-Enfields.) It's heavy, slow and has too small capacity. The Germans had an opportunity to produce something better in 1935 and, for what ever reasons, decided not to.