3-20-17 Garand Picture of the Day

[Mark in Rochester]

Here the Marine M4A3R3 Sherman tank - nicknamed the 'Zippo' by troops goes into action in Iwo Jima in March 1945

Information

Warning: This is a relatively older thread This discussion is older than 360 days. Some information contained in it may no longer be current.

[13Echo]

Effective but my God out of all the hellish ways to die there are in war it may be the worst.

[Bob Womack]

I read an expose on the flamethrower that said that those hit with a flamethrower didn't die via burns but via asphyxia. That's rather quick.

Bob

[Paul S.]

Effective but my God out of all the hellish ways to die there are in war it may be the worst.

I can't imagine being trapped in a turret of an on-fire Lancaster, Halifax, B17, or a B24 as it nose dives down from 20,000 feet is even remotely better. Sure, it's quick, but you know it's coming.

[matthanne1]

but you have to figure that the part of the reason that they had no oxygen was the superheated plasma and seared tissue. Never wished this on anyone.

[CINDERS]

Given the problems with having to ferret out deep bunker systems the IJA employed on these islands and the extremely robust pill boxes it stands to reason send in a flame throwing tank to spare casualties rather than risk fighting superior numbers in a dark black hole.
Most of the times the flames consumed all the oxygen if they were deep so they suffocated though in the pill boxes well they had no where to hide and suffered the consequences thing is with super heated air your lungs just crisp up and you'd pass out & die through no 02 therefore hopefully being spared the flames.
Plus given what atrocities the IJA had committed in Manila, Singapore and New Guinea against the allies well they really did not expect any quarter did they besides the Germans used the flame thrower as well as gas in the first world war no I reckon those to G.I's in the picture are cheering like Billy 'O at the destruction that Sherman is dishing out to the enemy.

When we did our firefighting they took us into a heat room where they had set a fire up to show incipient flash over and what it looks like, I thought it was pretty cool being shut in that room watching the flames run across the ceiling above us the temp was 300 degree F and we were advised to put our hand up if we wanted out and not to remove your B/A mask as your lungs would just shrivel up and you'd be dead, it was rather warm in there though........

[13Echo]

Cinders what you say is largely true but it still remains napalm and flame throwers are terrible weapons whatever the justification for using. If I were a GI in WWII I'd much rather use a Flame thrower than try to clean out a tunnel full of the enemy but it doesn't diminish the utter cruelty of the weapon. I guess we have the Germans from WWI to thank for that. Like Sherman said " War is cruelty."

[Mark in Rochester]

Livens Large Gallery Flame Projector

Livens Large Gallery Flame Projector - Wikipedia

[CINDERS]

The Livens one I watched on a doco before they were trying to follow the collapsed gallery to where the projector was to have been set up it really was a land of folly in WWI and would have remained so had it not been for the horrendous loss of life and appalling conditions.

[Gil Boyd]

What was the range of the Sherman projectile. That looks awfully close to those you want to toast!!