Thoughts on this WRA I cut Hi-wood Stock

[painter777]

WWII M1 Carbine Walnut Stock Winchester Mint High Wood - eBay (item 170494252635 end time Jun-13-10 18:42:32 PDT)

Information

Warning: This is a relatively older thread This discussion is older than 360 days. Some information contained in it may no longer be current.

[imarangemaster]

That is way too perfect. I don't claim to be knowledgeable in the collectible department, but that looks like it just came from the factory, and the cartouches are VERY crisp.

[usgicollector]

It doesn't even look like a WRA stock. I have been know to be wrong, but that one doesn't look right.

[imarangemaster]

The ends of the I cut don't look right. Holding it up to a picture of the I cut I sold, it looks too long, like a modified type II.

[usgicollector]

There are other physical differences from a WRA I cut highwood I am holding in my hands right now. There may be some differences in the stocks made by winchester, but this one is way off

[Dr342]

I would take a pass, mine is not a high wood but it just looks different from that one.

[Tired Retired]

The wood does not appear to be very old - it has no "seasoning". I am of the UNEDUCATED and NON-EXPERT opinion that it either its been stored in a museum case for the last 67 years or it is fresh cut. Plus the "w" in the sling well doesnt look right

[Bruce McAskill]

At least I am not the only one alarm bells are going off with this stock. Look at the width of the I cut. It might be the photo but is sure looks very wide for an I cut. Put all of the not rights together and it just screams fake. But wasn't this sell on Charlies list of do not buy froms?

[frankderrico]

The WRA/GHD doesn't look like the one I have. It's At $560.00 with two days left.....Frank

[jackthesmib]

recently manufactured - jmho