-
FREE MEMBER
NO Posting or PM's Allowed
-
07-09-2011 09:35 PM
# ADS
Friends and Sponsors
-
Moderator
(M1 Garand/M14/M1A Rifles)
There have been many posts on the subject of commercial ammo in the M1 Garand. With the exception of Hornady's target round designed specifically for the Garand, my last understanding was that there wasn't any commercial ammo that functioned well with the Garand without an adjustable gas plug. You can read some of the opinions HERE. The upshot of the problem is that modern power formulations burn too quickly, throwing off the timing of the Garand's gas system. A possible result can be a bent Op Rod. This can be ameliorated by the use of the adjustable gas cyllinder lock screws. There are two both available from Brownells, Shuster and McCann. The basic technique is to install the plug, open it up 'til the action doesn't cycle, then slowly adjust it down to where the action just cycles reliably.
Most folks stick with milsurp ammo (available from the CMP Store) but the adjustable plug gives you an option.
Of course, there could be other reasons for the problem.
Bob
"It is said, 'Go not to the elves for counsel for they will say both no and yes.' "
Frodo Baggins to Gildor Inglorion, The Fellowship of the Ring
-
Thank You to Bob Womack For This Useful Post:
-
-
FREE MEMBER
NO Posting or PM's Allowed
Thank you for the links. That said, the ammunition sold for the M1 Garand is not suitable for use in the Garand? I will say that the recoil felt different at times with it being the heaviest on the rounds that cycled correctly. Maybe I'll just wait to get my dies to continue to test function. I thought that factory ammo would be the best option for break in and baseline for operation.
-
Moderator
(M1 Garand/M14/M1A Rifles)
I wasn't aware that Federal was putting out a Garand load. Sorry about that. Around this board, most people suggest running milsurp ammo as the baseline when calibrating the rifle. I really don't know the characteristics of this round other than the fact that it has a 150 grain bullet and 2740 fps at the muzzle. However, I can tell you that the lowest price I found for it online was $19.95 for 20 rounds. That's a buck per pop. The Greek ammo from the CMP averages out to $0.53-0.54 per shot - right around half that. I wonder if the Federal primers are tough enough to handle the semi auto action? If not, there's the possibility of the firing pin firing it when the bolt slams home. Surely they thought of that when they spec'd it for the Garand, though. Hopefully someone better acquainted with the problem will wander by soon!
Good luck,
Bob
"It is said, 'Go not to the elves for counsel for they will say both no and yes.' "
Frodo Baggins to Gildor Inglorion, The Fellowship of the Ring
-
-
FREE MEMBER
NO Posting or PM's Allowed
I will have to get registered with the CMP. I bought the Federal ammo as a crutch to get by until I begin to reload. It is hard to determine what the condition of the op rod because of the refinishing. The rod looks perfect, but the piston shows some age. I was wondering if anyone has gotten similar measurements on theirs before. Or possibly knows what the inside dimensions of the gas cylindeer should be. Mine has obvious peening with scratches and gouges, but it fits very tight to the barrel. The problem seems to be in my opinion, a loss of gas pressure. The ammo may not be the genuine article, but it is loaded to mimic it. My next step will be either new cylinder or repair/replace the op rod. The latter being the least desireable. I know each rifle is it's own animal, just hoping someone had a similar experience!
As a sidenote, there was a gentleman at the range that said it is possible to braze brass to the piston and turn it down to size to allow the brass to be the bearing surface. I would rather avoid things like that, but does it hold water?
-
-
-
FREE MEMBER
NO Posting or PM's Allowed
The rifle has never functioned correctly since I've had it. In my efforts to find the problem I found the cracked gas plug. I replaced it to no avail. Maybe a marginal improvement since it cycled itself a few times after replacement. I see this as further evidence of blowby. I am a newbie and was just asking in the hopes that there was a clear answer. I guess it is just because I bought this particular rifle on an impulse, at a premium price, and I want to minimize the amount of $$$$ I'm throwing at it! I bought it from an individual as well, so there is little to no recourse.
-
Advisory Panel
True, maybe a new OP rod and gas cylinder will do it. I should think so. Just be careful of your source and let us know how this develops. The beauty of these rifles is that they CAN be rebuilt easily.
-
-
Legacy Member
If your op-rod piston is undersize as you say, ship your op-rod off to Columbus Machine in Ohio and have a new one installed. Much cheaper than a new operating rod. Maybe you can get lucky and find someone local with an M1 gas cylinder gauge so you know where you stand in that regard. Since your barrel is a commercial replacement, have you verified the diameter of the gas port in the barrel? Is the gas port obstructed at all when the gas cylinder is installed?
-
Thank You to Garandy For This Useful Post:
-
FREE MEMBER
NO Posting or PM's Allowed
You should have a piston gauge, and a set of cylinder gauges. You can sell them when you're done, or keep them like I did. I save $150. on an oprod, thanks to my gauges. I've never had trouble with Hornady or Federal M1 ammo, but I refuse to pay those prices. I suggest completely going over your parts, in case something else has been buggered up, and making sure your rifle is properly lubricated.
Charlie
Attachment 24751
Last edited by Charlie59; 07-12-2011 at 05:08 PM.