-
FREE MEMBER
NO Posting or PM's Allowed
-
01-09-2015 07:45 AM
# ADS
Friends and Sponsors
-
FREE MEMBER
NO Posting or PM's Allowed
Barrel no longer available
Barrel is no longer available.
Keith
-
-
Legacy Member
RIA barrel
VERY few RIA M1917 barrels were ever made. Easily a very rare barrel. It was a project that never got started and was cancelled shorty after starting.
-
-
FREE MEMBER
NO Posting or PM's Allowed
that looks pretty good for 50yds. You should get <2MOA on a good barrel and vertically it is. redo at 100yds.
---------- Post added at 08:59 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:52 PM ----------
The receivers are very strong, Ive never heard of a cracked one while putting in a new barrel!
-
Legacy Member

Originally Posted by
ssj
The receivers are very strong, Ive never heard of a cracked one while putting in a new barrel!
Eddystone manufactured rifles have the unfortunate reputation of cracking when swapping barrels. The belief is, Eddystone tightened the barrels on with machinery which way over tightened the barrel. The problem showed itself when the the rifles where rebarreled in WW2. I think? SOP is to make a relief cut when rebarreling Eddystones, maybe Chuck or one of the other guys can chime in.
-
Thank You to WarPig1976 For This Useful Post:
-
Advisory Panel
never seen a Eddystone with a crack, not saying that they wouldnt.
since all 3 makers used the same steel from the same supplier i dont know why one would crack easier then the others.
i have seen a few winchesters with cracks,
and all were from using the wrong tools, or using the right tools the wrong way..
all are cracked in the same place, from the same reason.
iv rebarreled hundreds of 1917s and have yet to crack one doing so..
-
-
Legacy Member
Thanks Chuck, That clears things up for me. Can't tell you how many times I've read and heard Eddystone's are prone to cracking. My guess would be it's because people have visions of machinery meant for Locomotive building being used to build rifles. That or it was started by a Winchester snob!!..
-
-
Advisory Panel
barrel install was done by hand,, by one man...and hand tools..
-
Thank You to Chuckindenver For This Useful Post:
-
Deceased May 2nd, 2020
I believe that chuckindenver once posted a video of barrels being installed on M1917's. They were doing it with a barrel vice and an action wrench by hand, not a special hydraulic machine as is often reported.
FWIW
-
-
Deceased May 2nd, 2020
M1917 vs M1903 Accuracy
I have often wondered how the accuracy of a service grade M1917 compared with a service grade M1903. I have only seen the results of one such test and it was relatively inconclusive since the sample size was so small and different ammunition and different numbers of shot were fired with the various rifles. I believe that when the National Matches were fired in 1918, it was requested that all rifles be of Remington Manufacture. In the test cited above the Remington was more accurate than the Winchester fired in the same test.
*In the test described above twelve 10 shot groups were fired with a Remington M1917 in service configuration and gave an average of 3.78 inches at 100 yards. Ten shots with 1939NM ammo gave a 2.72 inch group. The remaining shots were fire with a mixture of FA 1931 and 1932 M1
ball ammo.
* One M1903 in service configuration was fired fourteen 10 shot groups with an average group size of 3.71 inches. Six groups fired with 1932NM ammo resulted in an average of 3.98 inches at 100 yards.
*In the Winchester M1917 in service configuration six 10 shots groups with M1 ball averaged 4.22 inches. With 1932NM ammo the average group was 4.22 inches at 100 yards.
Again the number of shots fired and the number of rifles tested was so small as to render the results inconclusive. These tests appear in the January 1940 AMERICAN RIFLEMAN.
FWIW
Last edited by Cosine26; 01-16-2015 at 01:11 AM.
Reason: add data
-