As a former sailor, my best guess is that some OOD, along with the rest of the duty watch and the old man, are in deep dodo.
How a small, fast, destroyer type can be hit by a lumbering merchant vessel is inexplicable unless the whole bridge watch was badly distracted or asleep.
It happened around 3 bells on the mid watch. You would think that seeing both green and red nav lights on the horizon at the same time would get a lookouts attention. Curious to see what the Board of Inquiry will say.