I'm not planning to put a bright finish on it, just get the rust off. You do make a good point however as it appears that there is black paint or some other substance on it that is mostly worn off. The metal itself appears to be blackened somehow as well so I'm just going to be careful and get the orange off. I was going to do it today but our yard sale morning turned into an antiquing day near an amusement park we have season passes, food passes and drink passes at so we spent the second half of the day there eating too much, getting tired feet walking through the zoo and riding a couple of rides. Hershey Park for any that have heard of it. Pretty big in Pennsylvania.