corrosive?

[bearhunter]

Hot water and lots of it.

Information

Warning: This is a relatively older thread This discussion is older than 360 days. Some information contained in it may no longer be current.

[Pattern14]

Hot water and lots of it.

and a long necked funnel.

[Stevo]

and a long necked funnel.

Nah, if it's hot enough it'll dry quick anyway.

Actually, the only rifle I don't bother with a funnel is my VZ58. No wood to worry about on it.

[AKA Hugh Uno]

while the bore is still hot hot, then some Sweets (mostly water), then some break free, but usually I DON'T SHOOT THE STUFF (in enfields anyway) because there isn't any real need to do so, plus much of the cordite is "click-bang-confeitti" and far from precision ammo! LOL

[BerdanIII]

Butch's Bore Shine: there's water in the mix for the corrosive priming and it does a great job of removing jacket fouling. Bores cleaned previously with Ed's Red still show a bunch of crud on patches soaked with Bore Shine. (Disclaimer: I do not own stock in the company, am not an employee and have received no compensation for this post.)

[JBS]

Butch's Bore Shine: there's water in the mix for the corrosive priming and it does a great job of removing jacket fouling. Bores cleaned previously with Ed's Red still show a bunch of crud on patches soaked with Bore Shine. (Disclaimer: I do not own stock in the company, am not an employee and have received no compensation for this post.)

Strange, I spoke with the original inventor owner ( Charles ) of Butch’s years ago, we talked about how it almost got named Bore Squeak. He disclosed no water in the formula to me. It would have been next to impossible for Butch’s to past the 3M Laboratories three month barrel soak test if it had water in it.

Edit: I stand corrected. BerdanIII you are correct. I am down to my last bottle of original Butch’s from BBS Billings Montana. Yesterday I purchased a new bottle now made by Lyman. Sure enough the new label list water (7732-18-5).

[yodar]

Butch's Bore Shine: there's water in the mix for the corrosive priming and it does a great job of removing jacket fouling. Bores cleaned previously with Ed's Red still show a bunch of crud on patches soaked with Bore Shine. (Disclaimer: I do not own stock in the company, am not an employee and have received no compensation for this post.)

You ARE right. Butch's has a dash of ammonia for the copper that Ed's lacks.

One fellow has prepared Ed's Red with Strong Ammonia (from janitorial supply store) to Make Ed's PINK and it works well, but I prefer MilTec Pro or it's Hoppe's re-badged counterpart : Hoppe's Elite foam aerosol

Excellent product uses ammonia as a salt (Ammonium Oleate, I think) but it's got no odor and works well

yodar