Thanks for the tips, guys. Unfortunately, this guy isn't local, so that makes it a little more difficult. So far the only Garandicon I've found locally is way overpriced.
From what I've learned since I posted this, the guy who is selling it usually buys from CMPicon and then marks up. There were some complaints about him, but he apparently always fixes the problem. Maybe that's not the best way to go.

I do have another option with one I found online. It's a Danishicon CMP Garand. It has a VAR barrel and the receiver dates to 1943. All the wood is new and it looks pretty sexy. The Muzzle wear and TE are supposedly below 2. Unfortunately it doesn't come with any clips or warranty. I attached a picture of it. That may be a better choice, but I'm not sure yet.

I hate to buy without seeing it, but unless someone knows a place to get decently priced Garands in Tennessee, I'm not sure what else to do.