Yes, Peter, I think you are right about that. I have seen boxes with some recessed and some not. I think I will start recessing them from now on as it would look better.
When you don't recess the staples/posts you have to set the hasp 1/8 of an inch ahead, or past the front face of the lid. The reason for this is the back side of the hasp where the "keyhole" slot is has to fit flat against the round staple/post mounting disc so the hasp closes, or locks up tight. When I install the brass rivet I have to slightly countersink the rivet head with a forstner bit and this does not leave much room from the countersink to the face of the lid. Hope that make sense.
This picture shows closer detail of the brass rivet and if the backing plate for the staple/post was recessed the hasp would be set farther back and that rivet and countersink would also be set back 1/8 inch more from the face of the lid.
Thanks for that tip Peter, it's comments like yours that are helping my box builds to be closer to the originals than ever. Please keep the comments coming!