Saginaw from Legacy Collectibles what do you think?

[320th INF]

Guys,

Legacy Collectibles has a Saginaw currently for sell. I was wondering what you guys think. Looks nice, maybe too nice. Very limited description concerns me. Please see the below link.

Saginaw Gear M1 Carbine | Legacy Collectibles

Your thoughts please.

Thanks,

320th INF

Information

Warning: This is a relatively older thread This discussion is older than 360 days. Some information contained in it may no longer be current.

[painter777]

Boxed SG and CC stamps are fake. Can't get my photobucket to work, but trust me on the stamps. Other pictures are just vague enough to show zero detail.

Charlie-painter777

[320th INF]

Charlie,

Thanks for your insight. The stock looks too perfect and maybe a little dark. The photos are poor to say the least. I do trust you on the stamps - could you elaborate without photos - I looked at Riesch and Harrison (I know about him) and really could not see what you already know.

Thanks again.

320th

[painter777]

Actually I briefed thru all their carbines (except the troopers) and most all the Cartouches looked very iffy. Except that I cut WRA, that boxed WRA over GHD is legit along with the CC, I have 2 earlier versions in that serial range. I'm on the old laptop today, it won't let me pull pics from photo bucket, but I could at a later date if needed.

That boxed SG and CC exactly match the repro (I prefer-Fake) stamps they were selling on Ebay years ago.
The G has a too tall a profile above the cross - of the G. Much like the smaller versions that George uses on his fake flips.

I'll try to find links in the carbine forum for pics after dinner.

Little Later....
Charlie