"Shallow" is subjective. Viewing the picture the "dimple" appears about as deep as large in diameter. No punch or ball peen strike can physically do that. Both tools displace material around the strike. A ball mill will, but it cuts and there is no indication of material displacement around that dimple. Merely the opinion of a guy that spent 25 plus years working with and machining metal.
"You are what you do when it counts."