General cleaning question

[colt100]

copper fouling from bullets. and foam bore cleaners are a PURE GIMMICK. they don't work any better (and usually are less effective) than more aggressive bore cleaners such as Shooters CHoice, Sweets, Butch's etc.

Why are they a gimmick?

Information

Warning: This is a relatively older thread This discussion is older than 360 days. Some information contained in it may no longer be current.

[AKA Hugh Uno]

Why are they a gimmick?

when I personally tested Wipe-Out in these badly fouled barrels I got from CMP each a couple or more years ago, it was not nearly as effective as Sweets, Shooter's Choice, or Butch's). Were I to recommend ONE cleaner, it would be Butch's as it works very well and does not contain ammonia.

If I recall correctly (and I can't check right now), Wipe Out's major ingredients were WATER, SOAP, and Naptha. Thus, my additional concern, in an M1, would be water migration from the gas port hole to the op-rod. Which, without a wipe-off with a rust preventative, might RUST.

Wipe out is OK for BLACK POWDER clean up, but again, you would still have to deal with water-related issues.

Finally, WATER isn't a horrible bore cleaner in and of itself and can actually remove a bit of copper fouling, especially in a warm/hot bore when cleaning (post corrosive ammo usually) at the range.

Thus, I guess my use of the word "gimmick" was a bit excessive. Wipe-Out/Foams are not as bad as copper bracelets to reduce arthritas, but you can certainly clean copper out faster, cheaper, easier, perhaps safer?, with other products.

[JBS]

Interesting home tests. Gun Cleaning Product Tests

On a side note: Butch Fisher put his original Butch’s Bore shine on the market back in 99 I think. I joked with him once about how he should have named it Bore Squeak as that was the sound the second patch would make when bushed through the bore. He laughed hard and said he had notice that and though about it but decided it was to girly. Anyway I digress. He had 3M test the soaking effects way back when and got a no damage or etching report from them. He achieved this by using a buffered ammonia rather than common ammonia. The product now belongs to Lyman and I believe they have adjusted the formula a bit as it now has water listed on the label. I use it as an overnight soak on my match barrels and have several that have never been touched by a bore brush, the fouling, carbon and jacket wipe out with a patch. I miss Butch he was a hoot. Plug the bore and fill, let soak for a couple days for really bad bores.