Square P and ESSA on M1917 Stock

[HKGuns]

Cool! Thanks for the information......much appreciated. I was concerned it was a lame attempt at a fake.

Information

Warning: This is a relatively older thread This discussion is older than 360 days. Some information contained in it may no longer be current.

[Tom Doniphon]

Your carbine has a Red River Arsenal proof mark. Red River Arsenal also used the P in a square proof mark.

[Calif-Steve]

My Garand has the square P stamp. Also has the RRAD stamp.

[emmagee1917]

Well Jim , in this case he was asking if his Red River Arsonal rebuild would have a San Antonio Arsonal "P" in a square stamp. It does not . It has RRA "P" in a square stamp. But what you say is correct. I've seen a few stocks with three arsonal rebuild marks and I belive one with four. We must remember though , that each trip through , the stock may have not been placed on the gun it came in on. So , even if the stock is marked four times , it's no reason to think the rifle was through more than once. Chris

[JGaynor]

Well Jim , in this case he was asking if his Red River Arsonal rebuild would have a San Antonio Arsonal "P" in a square stamp. It does not . It has RRA "P" in a square stamp. But what you say is correct. I've seen a few stocks with three arsonal rebuild marks and I belive one with four. We must remember though , that each trip through , the stock may have not been placed on the gun it came in on. So , even if the stock is marked four times , it's no reason to think the rifle was through more than once. Chris

Right - that's why I said the marks indicated the stock was 'recycled'. It would be a minor miracle if a stock was reassembled to the same action during the course of a rebuild.

Regards,

Jim

[Johnny Peppers]

Several 1911A1 pistols are known with RIA, FK, and ordnance bomb stampings that are totally original pistols with nothing done to them. It appears that if it went to Rock Island, it got stamped whether they did anything or not. This may also apply to other weapons sent to arsenals and rebuild facilities.

[emmagee1917]

Many things dictated how a weapon was treated when it went through a rebuild facitity. They could be going through a large shipment comming back in country from a ( or several) large bases due to closures , reductions , or weapon upgrades. The guns may be in great shape and are just stripped , cleaned , inspected , reassmbled , stamped and sent on thier way.
During times of wars , large funding , lots of work , they did a lot of total takedowns , big batches of refinishing , and hodgepodge reassembling resulting in the mixmasters we so know and love.
There was also times of budget cuts , low manpower , little to do. In these times we may find guns that were stripped down , refinished , and reassembled with thier old parts , except for upgrades , stammped and sent out. Almost a custom rebuild that would be done at a small shop.These are rare due to the small output of the times.

The life and times history of the rebuild facilities and thier outputs would make a wonderful research project and collection in itself. Chris